Keep in mind it doesn't cost anything to list a product on Amazon, so just because you see something listed there, doesn't mean it actually sells. I think you are at least a decade too late to get $200, let alone more than $200. $200 was the going price when Everclear was at the height of their popularity, in the late 90's and early 2000's. Since that time the majority of the people who would pay that price already have at least one copy of the CD (several people on here have multiple copies), combined with the availability of the music digitally including some sourced from the studio master tapes, but to mention decline in active fans the going rate is less than $50.
Here is an example of the two most recent Ebay auctions for the CD:
$32.00 + 2.01 shipping on Oct 29, 2014 (http://www.ebay.com/itm/COLORFINGER-CD- ... 2c8f7a7218
$41.00 + $2.68 shipping on Aug 22, 2014 (http://www.ebay.com/itm/COLORFINGER-CD- ... 35db2f5e9a
I know of several more examples, but Ebay only saves sold auctions for 90 days.
Regardless, good luck to you, I hope this information helps.